(no subject)
Nov. 15th, 2009 12:00 pmHaving spent about an hour pushing buttons and testing limits in Google Wave, I would like to register my total lack of enthusiasm.
Seriously, it's like they took Gmail, Googledocs, and Gchat, smashed them together, picked out all the useful parts, and THREW THEM AWAY. Then bred the result with a messageboard circa 2002.
( Initial review )
Look, I know I'm a luddite. I don't embrace new technology. I barely allow it to give me a peck on the cheek. But when I try out new technology I try to be fair about its odds of being useful to me, and Google Wave appears to be the most useless app for my needs ever invented. That's not to say some people won't find it useful and helpful, but for what I need it to do, it fails badly. It lacks a lot of the simple utility that has made Gmail so ubiquitous. Its comment threading function is not as efficient as Facebook's, its posting function isn't as accessible as LiveJournal's, and its utility as a chat program is nonexistent. Even as a tool for betareading fic, it's not as good as Googledocs.
Wave is in beta, early beta, so I suspect it has a long way to go. I documented all these issues in a blip I made, which some other people have commented on with their own issues, and I would love to send this blip to the people who are working on Wave. Except, OH WAIT, THERE'S NO WAY TO DO THAT. I can't forward it as an email, I can't add them since they're not in my contacts, and I can't export the blip to a file to send to them.
I love Google, and Gmail, and the philosophy of simplicity that Google normally espouses. I don't know how Google Wave got past that philosophy, because it's clunky and complicated and beneath Google's usual standard.
Seriously, it's like they took Gmail, Googledocs, and Gchat, smashed them together, picked out all the useful parts, and THREW THEM AWAY. Then bred the result with a messageboard circa 2002.
( Initial review )
Look, I know I'm a luddite. I don't embrace new technology. I barely allow it to give me a peck on the cheek. But when I try out new technology I try to be fair about its odds of being useful to me, and Google Wave appears to be the most useless app for my needs ever invented. That's not to say some people won't find it useful and helpful, but for what I need it to do, it fails badly. It lacks a lot of the simple utility that has made Gmail so ubiquitous. Its comment threading function is not as efficient as Facebook's, its posting function isn't as accessible as LiveJournal's, and its utility as a chat program is nonexistent. Even as a tool for betareading fic, it's not as good as Googledocs.
Wave is in beta, early beta, so I suspect it has a long way to go. I documented all these issues in a blip I made, which some other people have commented on with their own issues, and I would love to send this blip to the people who are working on Wave. Except, OH WAIT, THERE'S NO WAY TO DO THAT. I can't forward it as an email, I can't add them since they're not in my contacts, and I can't export the blip to a file to send to them.
I love Google, and Gmail, and the philosophy of simplicity that Google normally espouses. I don't know how Google Wave got past that philosophy, because it's clunky and complicated and beneath Google's usual standard.